Tylenol Extra Strength 500mg
Tylenol$13.99
✓Generic Worth ItSave 57%
70%confidence
482votes
✓Verified Mar 2026
Generic Alternative
Up & Up Acetaminophen 500mg
Up & Up
Target
$5.99337
Same Quality
96
Close Enough
49
Not Worth It
Evidence (1)
Ingredients✓ Confirmedby adminApr 6, 2026
Up & Up Acetaminophen 500mg contains the same active ingredient at the same dosage as Tylenol Extra Strength. Generic acetaminophen is FDA-approved. Manufactured by Perrigo. Pharmacists consistently recommend generics as equivalent to name-brand OTC pain relievers.
Add Evidence
Sign in to contribute evidence on this comparison.